A Red Red Rose Critical Essay

On By In 1

Analysis Of Oh, My Love Is Like A Red, Red Rose, By Robert Burns

Robert Burns has created many magnificent poems but the most charming, is “Oh, my love is like a red, red rose”. This poem is the essence of all his artistic creativity. He has a particular merit because relying on folklore and the dialect of his country; he created a modern art that does not only belong to the culture of his country but all over the world culture. With his genius, Burns fascinates the reader by transforming Scottish folk songs into marvelous poems. With sweet music in his heart, the poet-speaker writes about a young woman who he loved beyond measures. On the background of amazing music, Robert Burns, plants a red, red rose on the heart of the reader. It looks like this lyric is written by a shaking pen that is not under Burn’s command but under a magic power of an emotional vibration, which sources automatically from an exquisite sense of spirituality. Without such vibration, Burns could not choose any word to create his immortal lyric. The secrets of this fascinating lyric can be detected in the light of a literary analysis of four stanzas, and the literary interpretation of every gleaning word.

The often-used first line makes the reader more familiar with poem. The speaker's love is expressed through two similes; his love is compared to “a red, red rose” and “the melody” (1, 3). The speaker echoes his sentiments by reinforcing two above similes with the phrases “That’s newly” and “That’s sweetly” (2, 4). Obviously, the color "red" is a symbol of passionate love and used in the form of alliteration such “a red, red rose” it shows how strong is the speaker’s feeling (1). Its appeal over time and comparison with the loved woman gives the reader the possibility to discover the speaker’s pleasant ways on articulating his passion. It is very interesting to know why above alliteration is used? The second line is the proper answer. While this particular red is such an exciting color of the flower, it is a repetition of this adjective amplifies the representation of an ideal state. The exclamation “Oh my” combined with alliteration “red, red rose” echoes together to show not only the nature of the speaker's love but it acknowledges the reader about the voice of poem (1). The poet -speakers express his love through this lyric. Love is expressed as “Newly sprung", pure, vital in a perfect state and the time could not blemish it (2). Yet this personification of love is not permanent. Similarly, to the rose, which can exist in this state only "in June," the beauty of the speaker's woman and his feelings could not stay frozen in time (2). The forms of beauty are temporary and they disappear to come again into another wonderful form. The speakers feeling toward the instable state of rose’s beauty catalyzes him to pursue another figure of speech for his love. Even though he put neatly side by side his love and “a red, red rose” on background of a lovely melody of songs it is again a temporary form of beauty(1). A song might be...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Compare and Contrast: "The Masque of the Red Death [by Edgar Allen Poe]" vs. "A Rose for Emily [by William Faulkner]"

542 words - 2 pages Most notably recognized for their strange and bizarre stories, both Edgar Allen Poe and William Faulkner wrote several disturbing narratives. As such, it is not surprising to find that Poe's story, "The Masque of the Red Death," and Faulkner's tale, "A Rose...

"Love in L.A." vs. "The Red Convertible" - Compare and Contrast

556 words - 2 pages The stories "Love in L.A." and the "Red Convertible" compares and contrasts in a couple ways. In both stories the car is used to progress through problems and to start problems. The setting, plot, characters, and other factors make both stories have common features and differ. Jake in the "Love in L.A." and Henry from "Red Convertible" both compare dramatically, though they contrast also. Settings in both short stories differ from country to...

The Thin Red Line compared to World War II (tutor's comment: i like that you see the comparison and soldiers do have dreams of something other than the hell they face.)

604 words - 2 pages The movie The Thin Red Line has a thin relation to World War II in the conventional sense. The battle of Guadalcanal is illustrated only briefly in the three hour movie. The underlying tone of the movie is more philosophical than historical. While the battle is related with...

A Bed of Red Flowers: In Search of my Afghanistan by Nelofer Pasira

1251 words - 5 pages According to Taylor culture is defined as a complex whole which includes knowledge, beliefs ,arts ,morals ,laws and customs and any other capabilities acquired by man as members of the society. Anthropologists like Hertzkorits define it as a man-made part of the environment. Kluckhon and Kelly define culture as all that is historically created design for living explicitly and implicitly, rational and irrational which exists at any given time as...

Quail in rose Petal Sauce. Through the magical realism in the Like Water For Chocolate, Tita express her love through cooking. Explanes Siginifance

533 words - 2 pages In Laura Esquivel's novel Like Water for Chocolate, magical realism is one of the most dominant themes of the novel. Like Water for Chocolate is a novel that uses magic in ways that will affect almost everyone around the source that produces the magic in a good or bad way. Like Water for Chocolate is a...

Life of robert burns

933 words - 4 pages Robert BurnsRobert Burns was known by the critics in his days as a literary genius, writing over 250 songs and hundreds of poems. Many critics didn't think much of him at the time because he was a heavy drinker and a womanizer. He had fifteen children, 6 of which were out of wedlock. Besides all that he was an...

To A Mouse, by Robert Burns and Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck

926 words - 4 pages 2011 Two Different Mice and Two Different Men To the average reader, “To a Mouse” by Robert Burns and Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck may initially look very similar, but after carefully critiquing and comparing their abundance of differences, their opinion will change. Steinbeck found his inspiration for writing the novel after reading that poem. His novel is set in Salinas, CA during the 1900s and is about migrant farm wrokers while the...

Book Analysis of "The Red Tent", by Anita Diamant.

1021 words - 4 pages After reading Genesis 34, it tells the story of Dinah, Jacob's only daughter, who is forcibly taken and raped by a powerful prince. Later she is saved by her brothers, after a highly detailed planned guerilla strike, without Jacob's knowing. In "

A Critical Analysis Of: The Red Badge Of Courage

1798 words - 7 pages Stephen Crane had a very short writing career, only about 10 years, and in that short time, he greatly influenced the world of writing. His first work to gain worldwide recognition was

A red house by the beach full of memories.

1009 words - 4 pages It was about seven meters wide, and sixteen meters long. In total, it stood approximately fifteen feet high and was painted a bright fire-truck red on the façade, and beige with a hint of gray on the sides and back of it. It also had three rectangular glass panels on the façade, sitting parallel to one-another and standing vertically. This solid object had a solid brown wooden panel beside the glass panels that could swing...

A Psycho-analysis of The Oval Portrait, and "The Masque of the Red Death" by Edgar Allan Poe.

638 words - 3 pages Poe uses The Oval Portrait to make a comment on life, particularly on things that he may have missed out on, for one reason or another. In particular, love, beauty, and seeing the truth about life. The narrator is the vehicle he uses for his...

Critical Analysis of Red Red Rose

After a superficial reading, it may seem that ‘A Red, Red Rose’ is only a one-dimensional love poem. However, that is not the case. Upon closer inspection, we can interpret the poet’s love for the Scottish maiden with his love for Scotland itself. It has long been a practice among writers to compare landscapes with the female body. This was especially popularised during colonial times. The coloniser was often depicted in paintings as well as a conqueror over the female body. In the eighteenth century, when Burns was writing, such paintings and works of literature must have been a pervasive influence on contemporary poets. Burns was no exception. In declaring his love for the young lady in this poem, Burns is actually declaring his admiration for his homeland. The way in which he lovingly describes the landscape of the island supports this interpretation. Finally, when he says that though he may move away from the maiden but will one day return to her, he is saying that he might travel away from Scotland but will surely return to his native country at some point of time in his

Poetic Devices

Rhyme scheme:

The first two stanzas of ‘A Red, Red Rose’ have the same rhyme scheme – ABCB. And the remaining two stanzas have a similar, but slightly different rhyme scheme – ABAB. Both these rhyme schemes are simple, and give the poem a sing-song rhythm. This simplicity of rhythm is a characteristic one readily associates with folk songs, and hence it is no surprise that Burns’ poem is no exception to this rule.

Rhetorical devices:

1st stanza:

Simile: This rhetorical device is used when an overt comparison is made between two different things. In this stanza, the poet uses the device of simile first when he compares his love for the Scottish maiden with a rose that is red in colour, and again when he compares his love to a tuneful melody, in both cases using the word “like”.

2nd stanza:

Apostrophe: This rhetorical device is used when a poet addresses an invisible audience through his or her poem. In this stanza, the poet uses the device of apostrophe when he tells the Scottish maiden (who is not visible to us as we are reading the poem) that she is attractive, that he is in love with her, and that his love for her is permanent.

3rd stanza:

Metaphor: This rhetorical device is used when a covert comparison is made between two different things. In this stanza, the poet uses the device of metaphor when he compares his life with the sands of an hourglass, but never uses the words “like” or “as” in the process.

Central Idea of the Poem

In this poem, Burns declares his love for his country with an allegory of his love for a Scottish maiden. He says his love will last even after he has died. He compares this love to the beauty and perfection of nature. He also says that though he may be bidding her goodbye, he shall one day return to his beloved, though a distance as large as ten thousand miles may separate them.

Themes of the Poem

Love for nature: As previously mentioned, Burns’ poetry was a major influence on the Romantics because of the similarity of his mindset with theirs. Just like the Romantics, in particular Wordsworth and Shelley, Burns is enamoured of nature. He uses natural metaphors in this poem for he feels that only with the beauty of nature can the beauty of his love be compared. This nature may be as soothing as the one that Wordsworth finds a refuge in, and may also be the turbulent one (as when Burns imagines the rocks of the earth melting in the intense heat of the sun) that Shelley admires.

Longevity of life: In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, the Elizabethans and the metaphysical poets all wrote about the brevity of life, and preached the philosophy of ‘carpe diem’ (meaning ‘seize the day’) to remedy it. However, Burns does not think like them. He feels that life is very long, and compare its passing with the slow movement of sand from the upper glass bulb to the lower glass bulb in an hourglass. He therefore knows that his long life might transport him elsewhere, away from his homeland. But he vows that he will return to Scotland, and that his love for her will survive the test of time.

Tone of the Poem and Conclusion

Tone of the Poem:

‘A Red, Red Rose’ is a poem that abounds in expressions of love, and promises made to the beloved. Its tone goes hand in hand with such content. One can sense the admiration in the poet’s voice. There is only a light tone of fatality when he talks about going away from his beloved, but in the moment, that disappears and is replaced with a love-filled promise to return.


‘A Red, Red Rose’ is one of Burns’ most popular poems, and one can easily see why. Its content is simple, and accessible to all readers (even those unfamiliar with the Scots dialect). More importantly, it speaks of the universal emotion of love – whether for a woman, or for a nation. In both cases, the subject matter is relatable and appeals to readers in all walks of life.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *